Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the Civil War

By Harry S. Stout

A well timed reconsideration of "just war," this landmark historical past heavily examines the ethical underpinnings of the struggle among the States

whilst the country tore itself aside in the course of the Civil conflict, the North and the South marched lower than the banner of God. but the real ethical points of this struggle have obtained little realize from historians of the interval. during this gripping quantity, Yale non secular historian Harry S. Stout demonstrates how either teams’ claims they had God on their part fueled the ferocity of the clash and its enduring legacy this day.

continuing chronologically from the election of Lincoln to the beginning of Reconstruction, Stout explores how the elemental ethical behavior of the battle shifted from a restricted clash fought over constitutional matters to a complete battle during which slaughter either off and on the battlefield was once justified because the merely capability to unconditional victory. As North and South alike enshrined their factors as sacred, a type of nationwide faith emerged according to martyrdom and rebirth via violence.

Drawing on a desirable array of Civil battle letters, sermons, editorials, diaries, and conflict pictures, Stout finds how women and men have been ensnared within the time’s patriotic propaganda and ideological grip and the way those wartime rules proceed to echo within the debates this day. guaranteed to galvanize a big reevaluation of this bloody and tormented interval and entice readers of James McPherson, Garry Wills, and David Herbert Donald, Upon the Altar of the Nation is a provocative and astounding exam of rationale and behavior, either off and on the battlefield.

Show description

Quick preview of Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the Civil War PDF

Similar American Civil War books

Sultana: Surviving the Civil War, Prison, and the Worst Maritime Disaster in American History

“One of the main riveting struggle tales i've got ever read…. Huffman’s gentle, intimate prose ushers you thru this nightmare as though you have been dwelling it your self. ”—Sebastian Junger, writer of the correct Storm The dramatic precise tale of the worst maritime catastrophe in U. S. background, Alan Huffman’s Sultana brings to breathtaking existence a sad, lengthy forgotten occasion in America’s Civil War—the sinking of the steamship Sultana and the lack of 1,700 lives, commonly Union squaddies returning domestic from accomplice criminal camps.

They Would Never Hurt a Fly: War Criminals on Trial in The Hague

"Who have been they? traditional humans such as you or me—or monsters? ” asks the world over acclaimed writer Slavenka Drakulic as she units out to appreciate the folk at the back of the awful crimes dedicated in the course of the struggle that tore aside Yugoslavia within the Nineteen Nineties. Drawing on firsthand observations of the pains, in addition to on different resources, Drakulic portrays the various contributors accused of homicide, rape, torture, ordering executions, and extra in the course of essentially the most brutal conflicts in Europe within the 20th century, together with former Serbian president Slobodan Miloševic; Radislav Krstic, the 1st to be sentenced for genocide; Biljana Plavšic, the one lady accused of conflict crimes; and Ratko Mladic, now in hiding.

Tried by War: Abraham Lincoln as Commander in Chief

The Pulitzer Prize? successful writer finds how Lincoln gained the Civil conflict and invented the function of commander in leader as we all know it As we have a good time the bicentennial of Lincoln? s start, this learn via preeminent, bestselling Civil struggle historian James M. McPherson presents a unprecedented, clean tackle the most enigmatic figures in American historical past.

Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era

Jam-packed with clean interpretations and knowledge, puncturing outdated myths and not easy new ones, conflict Cry of Freedom will definitely develop into the normal one-volume heritage of the Civil warfare. James McPherson's fast paced narrative totally integrates the political, social, and army occasions that crowded the 2 many years from the outbreak of 1 struggle in Mexico to the finishing of one other at Appomattox.

Additional info for Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the Civil War

Show sample text content

The language of martyrs sticks out as non secular language. relating to the Civil warfare, it really is non secular language devoted to political faith instead of to Christianity. through the war’s such a lot devastating years in 1863 and 1864, no americans have been stated to be demise for his or her Christian religion, yet lots of “martyrs” have been death for his or her nation. No Christian minister, within the North or South, may self-consciously invoke a civil faith equivalent to or enhanced to Christianity for its carry at the American people’s hearts and minds. but the language of martyrdom unearths how, no less than subconsciously, this conflict used to be producing via sheer volume of blood sacrifice a dwelling and colourful civil faith. by way of linking patriotism to Christianity and paying lip carrier to the prevalence of the everlasting over the temporal, ministers and other people may perhaps include the recent religion with no absolutely acknowledging precisely what they have been doing. 20 Tragically, America’s civil faith wouldn't contain the very freedmen and ladies such a lot of millions died to disencumber. And the following we come to the final word ethical failure of the warfare. The historian David Blight marks this because the crucial “tragedy” of the Civil battle: “The sectional reunion after so terrible a civil conflict was once a political triumph via the overdue 19th century, however it couldn't were accomplished with out the resubjugation of a lot of these humans whom the warfare had free of centuries of bondage. this is often the tragedy lingering at the margins and infesting the guts of yank background. ”21 Upon the Altar of the kingdom tells tricky tales of unjust behavior on either side of the fight. Understandably, so much americans favor to not face the facts of an immoral struggle, particularly whilst the conflict in query is the yank Civil conflict. yet i think that if we're to appreciate the that means of the US at the present time, then face it we needs to. The conclusions I reached on the finish weren't the assumptions I made first and foremost, simply as for the contributors the struggle intended something initially and whatever totally diversified on the finish. The Civil struggle used to be no longer a static occasion, yet really dynamic with ever-changing meanings and modifications as one bloody 12 months moved into the following. in simple terms after vicariously battling on the battlefronts and imaginatively dwelling at the domestic fronts did I arrive on the positions I current the following. this is often the event I want for the reader in addition: to stick with me and struggle the battles as they boost, and because the generals upward thrust or fall to the get together; to undergo throughout the prisons as ravenous males die in lonely and uncelebrated isolation; to witness the sight of once-proud ladies whose houses and husbands were destroyed begging for lowly employment; to visualize ladies and kids being bodily faraway from their houses and put in prisons; to recapture the faces of farmers helpless sooner than unchallenged armies massed on defenseless populations, in either the North and the South, with the aim of root-and-branch destruction. merely while the reader hears the anguished cries of the suffering—My God, why have you ever forsaken us?

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.55 of 5 – based on 29 votes